My Brute

Devlog: the Warrior was lagging behind, so we measured every class again

At level 100, a Knight won 28% of its fights and a Colossus 68%. The classes had been tuned without skills: the new measurement, the two causes and the fourteen settings changed on November 16.

A player wrote to tell us that their level 100 Knight stood no chance against the other classes. We checked, and they were right, by a wide margin: at level 100, a Knight won 28% of its fights against the other classes, a Colossus 68%.

Rogue
Rogue
Mage
Mage
Warrior
Warrior
Guardian
Guardian

The rebalance has been live since November 16. Here is what we found, what changes for each class, and what is still left to do.

The measuring mistake

When classes and specializations came out in October, each one had been tuned over thousands of simulated fights. The numbers looked good: everyone around 50%.

Except those simulated brutes had no skills at all. A real brute carries 14 of them at level 50 and 32 at level 100, and skills do not help every class the same way.

So we ran the measurement again, giving each simulated brute the skills that brutes of its level really carry, taken from the game. Here are the wins of each specialization against the other classes, at level 100, before the rebalance:

  • Knight: 28%.
  • Ravager: 37%.
  • Arcanist: 39%.
  • Duelist and Assassin: 53%.
  • Elementalist: 56%.
  • Bastion: 67%.
  • Colossus: 68%.

Lower down, it was no better. At level 50, the Mage won 69% of its fights, the Warrior and the Guardian between 36 and 43%.

Two causes

Heals that grow with HP. Five skills heal or protect as a share of their owner's max HP: Long Breath, Regeneration, RESURRECTION, Spectral Shield and Tenacious. For a brute with 800 HP, Long Breath and Regeneration restore 40 HP per turn. For a Guardian with 2,700 HP, they restore 135 per turn. The Guardian is the class whose stat gives HP: those skills were worth more than three times as much to it as to anyone else.

A class with no second effect. The Rogue's Agility counts in its damage, the Mage's Speed feeds its spells, the Guardian's HP is added to its blows. The Warrior's Strength gave damage and nothing else, as it does for any brute. It was the only class whose stat brought nothing extra.

What changes, class by class

No mechanic is removed and no talent moves. These are numbers, plus two additions: the Warrior's Raw Strength and the 1,600 HP rule.

Warrior

  • New mechanic, Raw Strength: your Strength counts 12% more in your blows.
  • Knight: block chance is multiplied by 2.4 instead of 1.7, and the riposte hits at 140% damage instead of 60%, three times per fight.
  • Ravager: below 50% HP, damage rises up to +280% instead of +170%.

Guardian

  • Weight adds 0.6% of your max HP to every blow, instead of 0.4%. That is what the Guardian was missing between levels 50 and 79.
  • Colossus: its Weight multiplier goes from 1.6 to 1.2, so the two increases do not stack.
  • Bastion: a block heals 90% of the blocked damage, instead of 33%.
  • The 1,600 HP rule, just below, concerns it first.

Mage

  • A spell hits at 50% of a normal blow, instead of 70%. That is what brings the Mage back in line between levels 50 and 79.
  • Elementalist: +50% spell damage, instead of +40%.
  • Arcanist: its spells used to hit at 90% of their damage, they now hit at 150%. It still casts a spell every other action.

Rogue

  • The share of Agility in damage drops by a hair.
  • Duelist: the second dagger hits at 40% damage, instead of 70%.
  • Assassin: +5% critical damage instead of +15%, and Death Mark gives +8% instead of +15%.

The 1,600 HP rule

This is the only change that touches skills, and only the five listed above. When one of them reads your max HP to heal or protect:

  • up to 1,600 HP, it counts them in full;
  • above that, each HP counts for 30%.

So a brute with 2,000 HP is read as 1,720, and a brute with 2,700 HP as 1,930. The Guardian from earlier recovers 97 HP per turn instead of 135. Below 1,600 HP nothing changes, and that is the case for almost every brute.

We first tried a cap: nothing counted above 2,000 HP. The balance was the same, but every HP earned past 2,000 became useless for those skills, and a stat that stops being worth anything past a threshold is a bad rule. We also tried halving the percentages for everyone: ordinary brutes lost out, and Guardians stayed between 55 and 60%. With the gentle slope, every HP still counts, just less.

Your HP itself is not touched: your health bar, your Weight damage and everything else still read your real max HP.

After the rebalance

Same measurement, same skills, thousands of fights:

  • Level 50: every class between 45 and 56%.
  • Level 65: every class between 45 and 56%.
  • Level 100: every specialization between 44 and 56%. The Knight goes from 28 to 46%, the Arcanist from 39 to 50%, the Colossus from 68 to 51%, the Bastion from 67 to 51%.

The Ravager remains the lowest at level 100, at 44%: it started at 37%, and pushing its low-HP bonus any further gave it outsized damage against the bosses.

What is not fixed

Level 80. That is the level where you pick your specialization, and it is still uneven: from 33% for the Ravager to 70% for the Arcanist. The reason is simple: a specialization's boost is the same at 30 talent points and at 50, while the tree itself is not filled the same way. One number cannot be right at both ends. The talent trees will need a pass, and that is the next balance project.

Investment still matters. These measurements compare brutes with the same level of gear. In the arena, a forged weapon and forged armor weigh more than the class: the Knight of the player who wrote to us goes from 25 to 35% wins against the real brutes of level 80 and above, and what it still lacks comes from its gear, not from its class.

The bosses follow

Classes no longer deal the same damage, so both raids were recalibrated the same day:

  • Mordrath: the grade of your assault (from F to SSS) is compared to the reference of your specialization. All eight references were recomputed.
  • The guild golem: its reserve goes from 500,000 to 550,000 from the week of November 23. The week in progress keeps its rules.

Thank you to the player who took the time to write. The measurement that had reassured us was wrong, and without that message we would not have run it again. If a class still looks out of line to you, the Support tab in Settings reaches us directly.

Read next

Tourne ton telephone en portrait pour jouer